| Year | Team | Record | MVP | Owner | Box Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Orangutangs | 8-6 | Harrison Butker | Jon Kinsman | Box Score |
| 2022 | Poop | 11-3 | Tom Brady | Brian Davidson | Box Score |
| 2021 | Refugees | 7-7 | Josh Allen | Anthony Aceto | Box Score |
| Darrel Williams | |||||
| 2020 | White Guys | 8-5 | Jason Sanders | Anthony Aceto | Box Score |
| Lamar Jackson | |||||
| 2019 | Buddies | 11-2 | Patrick Mahomes | Mike Kinsman | Box Score |
| 2018 | White Guys | 12-0-1 | Kyle Rudolph | Anthony Aceto | Box Score |
| 2017 | White Guys | 9-4 | Todd Gurley | Anthony Aceto | Box Score |
| 2016 | Eaters | 9-4 | Mark Ingram | Chris Davidson | Box Score |
| Philip Rivers | |||||
| 2015 | Dragons | 8-4-1 | Frank Gore | Jon Kinsman | Box Score |
| 2014 | Orangutangs | 8-5 | Tony Romo | Jon Kinsman | Box Score |
| 2013 | Chickens | 10-3 | LeSean McCoy | Mike Kinsman | Box Score |
| 2012 | Chickens | 9-4 | Drew Brees | Mike Kinsman | Box Score |
| 2011 | Merry Men | 9-4 | Matthew Stafford | Steve Dugas | Box Score |
| 2010 | Thugs | 9-4 | Mike Williams | Bobby Sansone | Box Score |
| Dwayne Bowe | |||||
| 2009 | Refugees | 7-6 | Donovan McNabb | Anthony Aceto | Box Score |
| 2008 | Dragons | 9-4 | Matt Stover | Jon Kinsman | Box Score |
| 2007 | White Guys | 9-4 | Derek Anderson | Anthony Aceto | Box Score |
| 2006 | Refugees | 7-6 | Maurice Jones-Drew | Anthony Aceto | Box Score |
| 2005 | Buddies | 10-3 | Larry Johnson | Mike Kinsman | Box Score |
| 2004 | Merry Men | 10-3 | Shaun Alexander | Steve Dugas | Box Score |
| 2003 | Thugs | 9-4 | Jeff Garcia | Bobby Sansone | Box Score |
| 2002 | Huskers | 12-1 | Tiki Barber | Kevin Sansone | Box Score |
| 2001 | Dragons | 10-2-1 | Marshall Faulk | Jon Kinsman | Box Score |
| 2000 | Dragons | 10-3 | Marshall Faulk | Jon Kinsman | Box Score |
| 1999 | Gooks | 9-3-1 | Mike Alstott | Jon Kinsman | Box Score |
| 1998 | Eaters | 10-4 | Chris Chandler | Chris Davidson | Box Score |
| 1997 | Boys | 10-4 | Brett Favre | Chris Davidson | Box Score |
| 1996 | Chickens | 11-3 | Irving Fryar | Mike Kinsman | Box Score |
| 1995 | Poop | 7-6-1 | Thurman Thomas | Brian Davidson | Box Score |
| 1994 | Poop | 7-7-1 | Morten Andersen | Brian Davidson | Box Score |
| 1993 | Buddies | 9-6-1 | Edgar Bennett | Mike Kinsman | Box Score |